The January Churn Myth: 2024 Data From 1,000+ SaaS Companies Shows Involuntary Churn Peaks in August
Everyone braces their retention team for January. Churnkey's 2024 data across 1,000+ companies shows involuntary churn is actually 78% higher in August.
Every November, we watch the same thing happen across SaaS retention teams: budget gets approved for a January push, dunning emails get rewritten, and someone schedules a "New Year's resolution" discount campaign to catch subscribers before they cancel. It's not an unreasonable instinct — RevenueCat has documented real refund spikes in January, driven by resolution-motivated signups that lose steam within days. But that pattern comes from consumer subscription apps, and a lot of SaaS teams have quietly borrowed it as if it applies to them too. It mostly doesn't.
Churnkey's State of Retention 2025 report pulled monthly churn data from over 1,000 subscription companies covering more than $3 billion in tracked revenue, 15 million subscriptions, and 6 million failed payments through 2024. The headline number isn't a January spike at all. It's that total monthly churn barely moves across the calendar — staying in a tight 9.44%–9.98% band all year — while the two components that make up that number, voluntary and involuntary churn, move in completely different directions depending on the season. Average them together into one monthly churn rate, the way most dashboards do, and both patterns disappear.
What the monthly data actually shows
Pull apart voluntary and involuntary churn by month and the picture gets a lot more useful than "watch out for January."
| Month | Total churn | Voluntary churn | Involuntary churn |
|---|---|---|---|
| January | 9.63% | 7.14% | 0.74% |
| February | 9.44% | 7.16% | 0.45% |
| July | 9.85% | 7.11% | 0.97% |
| August | — | — | 1.32% |
| September | — | — | 1.28% |
| October | 9.98% | — | — |
| November | 9.64% | 7.24% | 0.92% |
| December | 9.73% | 7.04% | 0.83% |
Three things jump out once you look at it this way instead of as one blended number. February, the month the "post-holiday hangover" story says should be bruised, actually has the lowest involuntary churn of any month in the table. October — not January — posted the highest total churn rate in the whole dataset. And November, which most teams treat as a calm lead-in to the holidays before things get busy, carried the highest voluntary churn rate measured all year.
Source: Churnkey, State of Retention 2025
The shape here is a slow climb through mid-year that peaks around August and September, nearly three times the February floor, before easing back down through the holidays. That's the opposite of what most involuntary-churn playbooks assume, which is that payment failures are roughly constant and only voluntary cancellations have a seasonal story worth planning around.
Why this doesn't look like the consumer-app pattern
RevenueCat's research on New Year's subscription churn is specific and well documented: refund rates for consumer subscription apps spike sharply in January, with health and fitness apps seeing refund requests jump 20% and peak at a 2.4% weekly rate in the third week of the month. That's a real, sharp, calendar-anchored effect, and if you run a consumer app sold on resolution-driven intent, you should absolutely plan for it — Cleeng's research on subscription retention makes a similar point, that credit card statements landing in early January trigger a "cut the recurring charges" reflex that catches subscription businesses using retail-style RFM segmentation off guard.
But Churnkey's dataset spans a much broader mix of subscription businesses, weighted more heavily toward SaaS, and the January effect essentially disappears into the noise. What shows up instead is a slower, less dramatic, but financially larger pattern: involuntary churn — the kind caused by expired cards, failed renewals, and bank-side blocks, not by a customer deciding to leave — tracks the months people travel, not the months they make resolutions.
We can't tell you with certainty why the summer bump happens; Churnkey's report doesn't isolate a cause, and neither should any post claiming to explain it with more confidence than the underlying data supports. The likely contributors are mundane: more subscribers are traveling and hitting international-transaction fraud blocks, more cards get reissued after summer travel and lost-wallet incidents, and billing teams are themselves running leaner during the same vacation months their subscribers are away. What matters operationally is less the exact cause and more that the failure volume is real and predictable enough to show up the same way three years running in Churnkey's data.
What to actually do with a flat total but a seasonal mix
Treat involuntary churn as a summer problem, not a background constant
Most dunning setups run the same retry schedule and card-expiry reminders year-round, on the assumption that failed payments arrive at a roughly even rate. If your own data echoes Churnkey's pattern, that assumption costs you recoverable revenue specifically in July through September. Our Stripe dunning guide covers the retry-window and email-timing mechanics that recover soft declines generally; the seasonal addition is to widen your card-expiry notice window going into early summer rather than leaving it at a flat 30 days year-round, and to make sure Stripe's Card Account Updater is actually turned on before the season where reissued cards start silently breaking renewals — it's a feature a surprising number of SaaS teams never enable, and it does its best work exactly in the window where cards change hands most.
Treat November as a voluntary-churn month, not a quiet one
If November is carrying your highest voluntary churn rate of the year, the worst time to go quiet on retention messaging is right before it. A pre-renewal reminder sent 7–14 days ahead of a charge works because it catches a subscriber before they've mentally exited, and that lever is worth pulling earlier in the fall rather than waiting for a January campaign that, per this data, is addressing the wrong month for a meaningful chunk of subscription businesses.
Don't confuse calendar seasonality with lifecycle seasonality
This is a different question from when in a subscriber's own lifecycle they tend to cancel — month one of their subscription versus month twelve. Calendar seasonality is about what time of year it is, regardless of when any individual customer signed up; lifecycle seasonality is about how long they've been a customer, regardless of the season. Both matter, and they're easy to conflate if you only ever look at a single blended churn number. A subscriber who signed up in March and cancels in August could be hitting a lifecycle risk window, a calendar risk window, or both — you can't tell which without splitting the data both ways.
Check your own calendar before borrowing anyone else's
None of this means January doesn't matter for your business — it might be your worst month, especially if you sell to consumers on impulse-driven intent. It means you shouldn't assume it without checking, and you shouldn't let a well-known consumer-app pattern crowd out a less-talked-about but larger pattern sitting in your own billing data. Pull your own cancellations by month for the last two years, split voluntary from involuntary the way Churnkey's report does, and look for which months actually carry your risk. Run the resulting numbers through our churn calculator to see how much a few points of seasonal variance are actually worth in dollars before you decide which season is worth building a campaign around.
A cancellation flow that only ever shows the same offer, on the same assumption that every month carries the same risk for the same reason, is leaving this kind of seasonal signal on the table. CancelFlow can route a subscriber to a different save offer depending on why their payment actually failed or why they're actually leaving, which matters more once you know those reasons shift meaningfully by month rather than staying constant like most dunning logic assumes.
Frequently asked questions
Is January really the worst month for subscription cancellations?+
It depends heavily on what you're selling. For consumer subscription apps, RevenueCat has documented refund rates spiking sharply in January as New Year's resolution subscribers bail within days or weeks — health and fitness app refunds jump 20% that month, peaking at 2.4% in the third week. But Churnkey's 2024 data across 1,000+ subscription companies (spanning both B2C and B2B SaaS) shows total monthly churn barely moves across the year, sitting in a narrow 9.44%–9.98% band. January isn't even the highest or lowest month in that range. The 'January is churn's worst month' story is real for impulse-driven consumer app categories and much weaker everywhere else.
Why does involuntary churn rise in the summer?+
Churnkey's report doesn't isolate a single cause, and neither should you assume one without checking your own data. The most plausible contributors are summer travel disrupting card usage patterns and triggering bank fraud blocks, a seasonal bump in card reissuance, and billing teams running leaner dunning operations during the same months customers take vacation. Whatever the exact mix, the practical point is the same: if your card-update and dunning campaigns are tuned for a January scare and quiet the rest of the year, you're under-resourcing the months where the data says more money is actually falling through.
When should I schedule retention campaigns if not around January?+
Run your own numbers before copying anyone else's calendar — ours included. But as a starting point: front-load card-expiry and payment-method-update campaigns before July, since Churnkey's data shows involuntary churn building through the summer and peaking in August. Treat November as a voluntary-churn month, not a quiet pre-holiday lull — it carried the highest voluntary churn rate of any month in the 2024 dataset. January deserves attention for consumer and app-based subscriptions specifically, where the resolution-and-refund pattern is well documented, but it shouldn't be the only month your team plans around.
Does seasonality affect B2B and consumer subscriptions the same way?+
No. Consumer subscription apps see sharp, calendar-driven spikes tied to things like New Year's resolutions and refund windows — RevenueCat's data on this is specific to that category. B2B SaaS churn is flatter month to month in aggregate, but the composition shifts: involuntary, payment-related churn tracks summer travel and card-reissuance cycles, while voluntary churn tracks budget review timing, which for many teams lands before the holidays rather than after them. Pull your own churn apart by voluntary versus involuntary and plot it by month before assuming either pattern applies to you.
Stop losing subscribers today
One script tag. One function call. A live cancellation flow in under 10 minutes.
Start free trial →